Hi Jorden
 
I usually tell me students that average is some fixed percentage (usually 80%) so if student try to game the system and give each other 10's they can only get 80% of the peer eval grade
 
I also have a number of instructors I work with that use the peer eval score as a multiplier with the team product grade.....this way average means you get the team earned grade....i.e. 75% times peer eval score 10 out of average 10 then you get 75%
 
There has been some concerned expressed by students on whether a bad member is good for the team allowing the other students to share more points.
 
Jim

From: Team Learning Discussion List [mailto:[log in to unmask]] On Behalf Of Jorden C. Sahl
Sent: Tuesday, March 11, 2008 7:32 AM
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: the math of peer evals

Hi Everyone,
I recently finished my second Introductory Psychology course using TBL. I have a question that is not that complicated but for some reason I can’t get myself around the math and I want to double check with other TBL users before I teach it again.
 
I used the Peer Evaluation form from the TBL book that assigns an average of 10 points, with one 9 and at least one 11 (max 15). A student asked me – so what does my average have to be to get “perfect” on the peer evaluations? And I was stumped (I had just never thought of it that way)
 
The max anyone can get would be 15, so I would assume in the rare case scenario of one person getting all 15s from their peers that would be “perfect”. But then, if 10 is average, is 10 “perfect” (I.e., if someone gets an average of 10, do they get 100% on peer evaluations, with the possibility for students to get higher than 100%)? (My class picked 30% for the peer evaluations grade weight). Calculating it this way (10 is 100%) increases everyone’s grade quite a bit (about half a letter grade), which I don’t have a problem with, as long as it is correct!
 
I am second guessing myself with the math and want some input before I use this method again.
Thanks so much.

 

Jorden Cummings Sahl, M.A.

Graduate Student, Clinical Psychology

Depression & Wellness Research Lab (302.831.2215)

University of Delaware

Newark, DE  19716

[log in to unmask]