Karla and others, One thing that seems to have helped my students buy into the TL concept and RATs is that I try not to refer to them as tests or quizzes, it sounds too punitive. I remind them frequently that the RATs are feedback for them to guide future studying and inform them as to the quality of their reading habits. It also allows me to tailor what we will do in the class based upon the feedback we all receive about the difficulty of the material. The activities I ask of my class change each semester depending upon the outcome of the RAT. Both the students and I need to know what they need before we can go there. If the amount of RAT points is small relative to other things in the course (exams, etc.) then it makes it a bit easier for students to swallow that as well. I agree with David, students are well trained at being passive in classrooms. They have been told to sit down and be quiet since Kindergarten. I have found that it is helpful to remind them of that. You may also want to ask them to look forward and anticipate what their "learning" will be like in the workplace. It might help them to see more value in becoming responsible and independent in the classroom. Just my 2 cents. Scott Kubitz, Karla wrote: >Hello TBL colleagues, > >I've a couple of questions that I'd like to put out there for some >feedback. > >First, how do you tell whether your RATs are too hard? My students have >been averaging about 66-67% on their individual RATs and about 93-94% on >their team RATs. That's across three classes and across 4 RATs so far >this semester. Does that sound like they're too hard? > >Second, I just did a class session to look at team processes (along the >lines of the one suggested in Michaelsen's book) where you ask the teams >what behaviors have helped, hurt, etc. I also included the question >about what the instructor could do to make the class better. In both of >my classes, I got the suggestion to lecture before the RATs instead of >after. Any suggestions on how to respond to the classes about this >suggestion? > >Karla > > > -- Scott D. Zimmerman, Ph.D. Associate Professor of Biology University of Wisconsin-Stout 410 10th Ave. Menomonie, WI 54751 Ph: 715.232.1448 Fax: 715.232.2192 [log in to unmask]