Bob Herring (& others),
I am forwarding to the TBL listserv a question that Bob Herring posed to
me. Both the question (see his email below) and my initial answer
seem like something everyone might benefit from.
Basically you are asking what one does in the assessment phase of TBL
that comes after the practice application phase.
There are
two options here, both of which are fine. Sometimes the professor
can give a regular end-of-unit written exam. And this may be
individual or a group exam. This is likely to be a mix of content
("understand and remember") kinds of questions along with
application problems.
The other
option is to give the groups a "culminating
exercise". This would be a project that they might work on
for a class or two that is big enough to require knowledge of and an
ability to apply the full range of concepts encountered in the unit (or
in the whole course, up to that point in time).
One
example that Michaelsen has used in a course that combined management and
computers, was a hypothetical daycare center. It was a
"mom-and-pop" operation, grew, and needed a computer system of
record keeping to replace the paper/pencil system. Question for the
teams:
- What hardware would you recommend?
- What software would you recommend?
- What procedures would you recommend?
After working on this for awhile, each team had to post a synopsis
of their choices on a flip chart sheet and post it on the wall. The
task promoted practical thinking : how would you solve this
problem? Then all the teams reviewed all the sheets and had to
select the ones they thought were best and that had the biggest question
or concern for them. This promoted critical thinking.
Another
example comes from microbiology. After studying microbial
physiology for several weeks, one professor gave each of the teams a new
genus of bacteria to learn about and then asked them to plot the
"likely path" of some component through the physiological
processes. They too had to post their decisions and then review
what other groups put up.
Both
examples require students to know, apply, and integrate lots of
knowledge, concepts and principles, i.e., the "content" of the
course. In that sense, these are good culminating exercises for
assessment. Sometimes students have to write individual short
papers, reflecting their individual understanding of the problem.
Note that the professor needs to be able to grade/assess the group
products. This means he/she needs to think about what criteria
separates a good from a mediocre or poor solution to the problem and make
those criteria clear to the students.
Does that help?
Do other
people have examples to share, of what you did in the assessment phase
when you used TBL?
Dee Fink
Date: Thu, 04 Sep 2003 19:15:35
-0400
From: "Herring, Robert" <[log in to unmask]>
To: 'Dee Fink' <[log in to unmask]>
Cc: "[log in to unmask]"
<[log in to unmask]>
X-Mailer: Internet Mail Service (5.5.2650.21)
Original-recipient: rfc822;[log in to unmask]
Dee: You gave a workshop at
Radford Univ. in VA at the beginning of January in 1995 or 1996; that's
how I first learned about TBL. I've been wanting to try it, but the
time was never right until now. I have a small evening section of
Business Policy (only 7), so I'm working them as one team. The mix
of students seemed too good to pass up this opportunity, although I
realize that only one team is not optimal.
Also, I saw Larry at ABE last
Sept., and OBTC in June, and got the TBL book on inter-lib loan; all that
inspired me as well.
I do have one question.
After the application phase comes the assessment phase; is a test per se
normally used there? Or is there a page in the TBL book that I've
overlooked.
I'm excited to begin this
process.
Bob
Robert A. Herring III, Ph.D.
Associate Professor of Management
School of Business and Economics
CB-19372
Winston-Salem State University
Winston-Salem NC 27110
Phone: 336-750-2288/2330
Fax: 336-750-2335
E-Mail: [log in to unmask]
E-mail is subject to monitoring
- -----Original Message-----
- From: Dee Fink
[mailto:[log in to unmask]]
- Sent: Thursday, August 28, 2003 10:55 PM
- To: [log in to unmask]
- Cc: [log in to unmask]
- Subject: Re: TEAMLEARNING-L: [log in to unmask] joined the
list
- Robert,
- Welcome to the Team-Based Learning (TBL) listserv!
- We'd love to find out a little more about you.
- How did you find out about the TBL website?
- Are you already using team-based learning, or just learning about
it? If the former, how did you find out about it?
Dee Fink
At 04:10 PM 08/28/2003 -0500, you wrote:
[log in to unmask]